XingfenD
37a0a8ddd1
The full-branch review of chore/p15a-approve-phases returned APPROVE with notes: the merged branch code itself has zero defects, but four places in this spec disagreed with the code it describes. All four came from the controller writing executable details from memory during the first re-pin. N1 - applyApprovalInTx parameter order, three places (D-C row, the §3.1 skeleton call site, the §3.2 phase-six signature). The spec said `plan approvePlan, submissionID`; the code has always been `submissionID string, plan approvePlan`. The implementer's order is legal and better: a scalar identifier before an aggregate matches Go convention. N2 - §3.2 migration ranges the first re-pin claimed to have fixed but had not: 48-85 -> 48-86 (86 is the closing brace of the coverUpload block) and 87-100 -> 88-101 (87 is a blank line, 88 is `switch sub.Kind`). N3 - the §1.2 difference-table header: phase four 87-100 -> 88-101, phase six 136-186 -> 136-199 (186 is a mid-branch line inside MetadataChange; 199 is the closing brace of the switch). N4 - §T1.4 said the CG2 needle's only hit is `:196`, which is the pre-F9 line number from dda3fe8; HEAD measures `:201`. The (b) blind-spot note said "126-200 = 77 lines"; 126-200 is 75 lines - 77 belongs to the §1.1 range 125-201 and was carried over by mistake. Every corrected value was re-derived from the base tree fe810dd and HEAD b15c2a8 line by line rather than copied from the review, and the two derivations agree. A RE-PIN note at §3.2 phase six records the true values and the lesson, which §8 discipline 11 now states as a rule: executable details in a spec (regexes, signatures, literals, line ranges) must be grepped out of the code entity and pasted, never hand-written. Post-write checks: 20/20 assertions, table column counts unchanged (12 blocks, 0 anomalies), 8 code fences paired, 28 headings with no duplicates. Closes N1-N4 of crearte-server/.superpowers/sdd-p15a/final-review-report.md. N5 (the verification artifact's fake rigor) is closed separately in the gitignored evidence area: verify-fix-v8.py now runs 106 real checks with zero bare prints, and the v2 output it cites is archived on disk.